What’s the best silver coin to buy right now?

Silver has been all over the headlines recently, in large part because of the recent price movement that propelled it from about $30 in early 2025 to over $100 per ounce one year later. The price of silver has slipped closer to $80 per ounce in the time since, but the precious metal’s recent volatility has still drawn in both longtime investors and newcomers who are exploring alternatives to traditional portfolios. But unlike investing in gold, buying physical silver means navigating a less cohesive market, one with choices that can significantly impact your actual returns, regardless of where spot prices head next.

Walk into any coin shop or browse online dealers, and you’ll encounter an array of silver investing options. Government-minted coins from multiple countries. Private mint rounds that look nearly identical to official bullion. Limited edition pieces that are marketed as collectibles. Each category carries different premiums over the spot price of silver, which can, in certain cases, be dramatically different, impacting your upfront costs, the potential returns when you sell and the amount of silver you can afford to invest in.

But those premium differences don’t tell the whole story, and choosing based solely on who offers the lowest price per ounce can backfire when it’s time to sell. So, if you’re planning on buying silver coins in today’s market, which options should you consider right now? That’s what we’ll detail below.

Start adding silver to your investment portfolio today.

What’s the best silver coin to buy right now?

If you’re focused on silver coin exposure, here are a few options you may want to consider in this market:

Government-minted bullion coins 

Coins from the U.S. Mint, Royal Canadian Mint, Austrian Mint and Perth Mint carry government backing for weight and purity. These types of silver coins represent the premium tier of silver investing and typically contain one troy ounce of .999 or .9999 fine silver. Premiums on these options tend to run a few dollars over spot, meaning you’ll pay more for them overall, but what you’re paying for is universal recognition and superior liquidity. 

When it’s time to sell your silver assets, most precious metals dealers will quote a fair price for these easily recognizable government-minted coins, typically without extensive verification required. So, if your priority is flexibility and you want to know that you can convert silver back into cash without friction, bullion coins still tend to make the most sense, even when premiums are elevated.

Diversify your investment strategy with gold and silver now.

Generic silver rounds 

Private mints produce 1-ounce silver rounds that match government coins in metal content but lack legal tender status and official backing. Premiums on these options can be substantially lower than government-minted alternatives, making them one of the most budget-friendly ways to hold smaller amounts of physical silver. 

The tradeoff, though, comes in the form of verification risk and potentially lower buyback prices. Precious metal dealers may scrutinize these rounds more carefully and offer less favorable rates when you sell. However, for pure silver bullion investors who are focused solely on maximizing ounces per dollar, generic rounds deliver the most metal for your money. And, they work particularly well for long-term investors who plan to hold through multiple market cycles and aren’t concerned with frequent trading.

Pre-1965 U.S. silver coins 

Older U.S. dimes, quarters and half-dollars that were minted before 1965 contain 90% silver and are often referred to as “junk silver.” These coins carry no collectible premium but are valued for their silver content and recognizability.

In uncertain markets, some investors like junk silver because the coins are widely trusted, easy to authenticate and often easy to sell in small increments. You’re not locked into unloading a full ounce at once, which can be appealing for people who view silver as a form of emergency liquidity.

The downside right now is that premiums on junk silver can fluctuate wildly depending on supply. When demand spikes, the markup over melt value can rise quickly, sometimes narrowing the cost advantage compared to bullion coins or rounds.

Collectible and numismatic coins 

Numismatic or semi-collectible silver coins sit in a different category completely. The value of these coins depends not just on silver prices, but on rarity, condition and collector demand. In a hot silver market, collectible premiums can become detached from fundamentals. That can work in your favor — or it can work against you. 

Unless you understand grading, rarity and resale channels, though, collectible silver coins introduce an extra layer of risk. So, for most investors looking to gain exposure to silver right now, silver collectibles make more sense as a niche addition, not a primary way to own silver.

The bottom line

The best silver coin to buy right now depends on your priorities. If liquidity and ease of resale are most important, government-minted bullion coins remain the gold standard despite their higher premiums. If your goal is to maximize ounces on a budget and you’re willing to hold long-term, generic rounds can deliver more metal for less money. And if you’re looking for fractional flexibility or a hedge that feels more familiar, junk silver offers recognizability and divisibility that larger bullion pieces can’t match.

What matters most, though, is matching your choice to your investing timeline, risk tolerance and exit strategy. Silver’s volatility means the decisions you make today — and not just whether to buy, but what to buy — can influence both your costs and your options down the road. So, take the time to understand the tradeoffs, compare dealer pricing and build a position that serves your goals, not just the current market mood.