Social media was buzzing this week after an analyst gave Cassius Winston the nod over Purdue’s Braden Smith in a 2020s All-Big Ten list
Who is a better and more accomplished point guard: Michigan State’s Cassius Winston or Purdue’s Braden Smith? This question has been a hot debate on social media this past week.
Rapheal Davis of the Big Ten Network sparked a hot debate this week when he unveiled his All-Big Ten teams of the 2020s, with one of the biggest discussions on social media being centered around Winston and Smith. Davis gave Winston the nod as the first team selection at point guard over Smith — who landed on Davis’ second team. It’s even more notable that Davis that gave Winston the nod over Smith since Davis played at Purdue himself and could have easily gave his former school’s guy the nod in a toss-up decision.
Davis noted that Smith could surpass Winston with a strong upcoming senior season, but some (probably many Purdue fans) felt he already deserved the nod over the Spartans legend. When comparing the two star point guard’s careers, they are very much similar with both experiencing both personal and team success during their time in college. Smith, of course, still has one more year to further improve his legacy — and it doesn’t hurt his case that the Boilermakers are considered a preseason top five team nationally (in large part to his return for his senior season).
To complete a side-by-side comparison, here is a link to Winston’s sports reference page and here is a link to Smith’s.
So who would you personally give the nod too? If you’re reading this article, you’re probably like me and a Spartan, which means you would lean towards Winston. But I do respect the argument for Smith, and wouldn’t be opposed to him moving into the first team slot should he have another strong year this upcoming season. Regardless of which way you lean, it’s a fun debate to have in the middle of July and I personally thank Davis for putting this list together for some fun Big Ten basketball banter in the heart of summer time.
Click on Davis’ social media post below to see his three All-Big Ten teams of the 2020s and to also check out the replies in relation to the Winston-Smith debate. There are definitely some good responses in favor of both the Spartans and Boilermakers lead guy at point guard worth taking a look at on X.
Contact/Follow us @The SpartansWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Michigan State news, notes and opinion. You can also follow Robert Bondy on X @RobertBondy5.