Instagram/@hbo
On Max now: This documentary is a women-driven documentary about Jayne Mansfield with her daughter, Mariska Hargitay, narrating. It tugs at the painful dichotomy of a woman trapped in the limbo of public perception and personal reality. The tension was perfectly captured in an archival clip where Groucho Marx slammed Mansfield’s act: “You’re not the dumb blonde that you pretend to be,” Marx said flatly. The confrontation felt admiring and heartbreaking in the context of her answer: “The public pays money to see me in a certain way… so I think it’s just all part of the role I’m playing as an actress.”
Advertisement
Currently, viral on several social media outlets, the content has catalyzed intense emotional responses toward the revelations of the documentary. That user was ecstatic over how Mansfield said so much without actually “saying a lot” during the Groucho interview, the smile betraying the complexity of being simultaneously seen in that moment yet locked into expectations. Another lamented tragic parallels with Marilyn Monroe, retorting how many dreams had been destroyed by Hollywood’s insistence on maintaining such narrow personas.
The whole discussion of Mansfield’s relations with her kids will hit close home. Many came out tearful after seeing clips that exhibited Mansfield really supporting the kids, so contrary to the Jayne that the world had known so far. “One of the things that touched me most was how much she loved her kids,” said one viewer, while another praised Mariska for “breaking cycles” after telling her mother’s truth after these many years.
Another layer of debate was seeded through the Groucho moment; some thought his blunt manner was forward-thinking to the period-“He SAW her” said one-while another felt aggrieved by that tone: “I can’t help but hear the contempt in his voice,” said one commenter, accusing Marx of being frustrated with Mansfield for playing along with the system rather than challenging it head on.
It also delves into how talk-show hosts of the day were known to work against the interest of Mansfield and other female stars. One shocked viewer vented: “Couldn’t get over how these TV hosts were allowed to speak to women,” and then she started a thread in which they compared how Mansfield was treated to cases involving Brooke Shields, Britney Spears and others. Its historical importance raises Mansfield higher in all her quiet power and marks these acts that this daughter is just beginning to remedy.
What this documentary and the audience reactions much more truly present is the life of the true Jayne, far from the cartoonish caricature history paints. Indeed, she was a classically trained musician (quite a few comments came out of the blue about her piano and violin prowess), a devoted mother, and, tragically, an artist who truly knew the game she was barely able to play. As one viewer so aptly put it, “The world now knows Jayne for who she was and who she wanted to be known for.”
Advertisement
The presence of so many viewers at the documentary exhibited the public’s hunger for a more nuanced reappraisal of some of these misunderstood icons. It’s sadly relevant even today when female celebrities still struggle with their public image, giving further strength to her daughter’s tribute. Unfortunately, this documentary neither praising Jayne Mansfield nor memorializing her; however, it has finally allowed for the creation of an actual woman that in life was denied.